Aminoethoxyvinylglycine rates and timing affect fruit quality and physiological disorders of ‘Gala’ apples
Yosef Al Shoffe,Christopher B. Watkins
Horticulture Section, School of Integrative Plant Science, College of Agriculture and Life Sciences, Cornell University, Ithaca, NY, 14850, USA
Abstract
Aminoethoxyvinylglycine (AVG) is a preharvest plant growth regulator that is commonly applied to apple trees to manage harvest by delaying fruit maturation. However, the effects of the different rates and application timing of AVG on fruit quality are not well known. In this two-year study the effects of AVG on fruit quality and physiological disorders was carried out by comparing half rates of AVG applied at 21-28 days before first anticipated harvest with and without an additional application closer to harvest, with a full rate applied 7 days or less before harvest. Fruit were stored in controlled atmosphere storage for up to 8 or 9 months depending on the year. Maturation of the fruit was delayed by AVG treatments compared with untreated fruit, but less so in the full rate treatments than the earlier half rate treatments. Development of the major physiological storage disorders stem end flesh browning and flesh browning was associated with more mature fruit. Disorder incidences were reduced by AVG, but less so by treatments close to harvest. Early applications of AVG, either as a single half rate or with an additional half rate, are recommended to maintain quality and minimize development of physiological disorders of long-term CA storage of ‘Gala’ apples.
摘要
氨基乙氧基乙烯基甘氨酸(AVG)是一种采前植物生长调节剂,通常施用于苹果树,通过延缓果实成熟来管理采收。然而,AVG不同施用浓度和时期对果实品质的影响尚不明确。在这项为期两年的研究中,通过比较在首次预期采收前21-28天施用半量AVG(有或无临近采收时额外施用一次)与在采收前7天或更短时间内施用全量AVG的效果,研究了AVG对果实品质和生理失调的影响。果实储存在气调贮藏中,根据年份不同,最长贮藏8或9个月。与未处理果实相比,AVG处理延缓了果实成熟,但全量处理的延缓效果不如早期半量处理。主要生理贮藏失调——果梗端果肉褐变和果肉褐变的发生与果实成熟度较高相关。AVG降低了失调发生率,但临近采收时的处理效果较差。建议早期施用AVG,无论是单次半量还是额外补施半量,以维持‘Gala’苹果长期气调贮藏的品质并尽量减少生理失调的发生。
Keywords
Malus x domestica; AVG; Flesh browning; Controlled atmosphere storage; Plant growth regulators; IAD values
关键词
苹果;AVG;果肉褐变;气调贮藏;植物生长调节剂;IAD值
Introduction
Aminoethoxyvinylglycine (AVG) is an inhibitor of ACC synthase, which catalyzes the conversion of methionine to 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylate (ACC), the precursor to ethylene in the ethylene biosynthetic pathway (Boller et al., 1979). The action of AVG in affecting apple fruit maturation and ripening is assumed to be primarily through this action, although AVG binds to pyridoxal-5′-phosphate, and therefore, action through non-ethylene pathways cannot be excluded (Le Deunff et al., 2019). AVG, as the commercial product ReTain® (Valent BioSciences LLC, Libertyville, IL, USA), is an important plant growth regulator (PGR) that is used to manage apple harvest in the apple growing regions where it is registered for use.
引言
氨基乙氧基乙烯基甘氨酸(AVG)是ACC合酶的抑制剂,ACC合酶催化甲硫氨酸转化为1-氨基环丙烷-1-羧酸(ACC),而ACC是乙烯生物合成途径中乙烯的前体(Boller等,1979)。AVG影响苹果果实成熟和后熟的作用被认为主要通过这一机制实现,尽管AVG能与吡哆醛-5′-磷酸结合,因此不能排除通过非乙烯途径的作用(Le Deunff等,2019)。AVG作为商业产品ReTain®(Valent BioSciences LLC,美国伊利诺伊州利伯蒂维尔),是一种重要的植物生长调节剂(PGR),在已登记使用的苹果种植区用于管理苹果采收。
The initial focus of AVG use was to reduce preharvest drop, especially cultivars such as ‘McIntosh’ that are highly susceptible to preharvest fruit drop (Greene, 2005; Schupp and Greene, 2004). Although the use of AVG to control fruit drop remains important (Arseneault and Cline, 2016; Trejo et al., 2023) there is less emphasis on this control as plantings of cultivars such as ‘McIntosh’ that have excessive drop have declined. AVG has become increasingly important for apple growers as strategy to delay fruit maturation and ripening (Doerflinger et al., 2019; Liu et al., 2022; Ortega-Salazar and Torres, 2026; Scolaro et al., 2015; Wargo et al., 2004) thereby allowing management of harvest of cultivars with overlapping harvest windows as well as dealing with labor shortages.
AVG使用的初始重点是减少采前落果,特别是‘Mclntosh’等极易发生采前落果的品种(Greene,2005;Schupp和Greene,2004)。尽管使用AVG控制落果仍然重要(Arseneault和Cline,2016;Trejo等,2023),但随着‘Mclntosh’等落果严重的品种种植面积下降,对这一控制的重视程度有所降低。AVG作为延缓果实成熟和后熟的策略,对苹果种植者变得越来越重要(Doerflinger等,2019;Liu等,2022;Ortega-Salazar和Torres,2026;Scolaro等,2015;Wargo等,2004),从而可以管理采收期重叠的品种的采收,并应对劳动力短缺问题。
The initial preharvest interval that was registered for AVG application was 21 to 28 days but this was updated in 2006 to 7 to 28 days. The optimal application rates and timings are affected by cultivar and growing conditions, and many different combinations are used by apple growers. A major concern, for example, is the negative effect of AVG on development of red skin color (do Amarante et al., 2010; Doerflinger et al., 2019). For ‘Gala’, the major cultivar grown in the USA, typical rates are a third to a half of the full label rate applied 2-4 weeks prior to anticipated first harvest, sometimes followed by another half rate sprayed about a week prior to first harvest (pers comm.). Another PGR, Harvista™, based on inhibition of ethylene perception by 1-methylcyclopropene (1-MCP), has a preharvest interval of 3 to 21 days, but is usually applied to trees 7 days before first harvest.
AVG最初登记的采前间隔期为21至28天,但2006年更新为7至28天。最佳施用浓度和时期受品种和生长条件的影响,苹果种植者使用许多不同的组合。例如,一个主要关注点是AVG对红色果皮着色的负面影响(do Amarante等,2010;Doerflinger等,2019)。对于美国主要栽培品种‘Gala’,典型用量为在预期首次采收前2-4周施用标签全量的三分之一至二分之一,有时在首次采收前约一周再喷施一次半量(个人通讯)。另一种植物生长调节剂Harvista™基于1-甲基环丙烯(1-MCP)抑制乙烯感知,其采前间隔期为3至21天,但通常在首次采收前7天施用于树上。
Information about the effects of the timing of AVG applications on fruit maturation and storage quality is limited. In early work, Greene (2005) found that applications made 1-2 weeks before anticipated harvest extended drop control beyond the normal harvest period, but applications made 4-6 weeks before harvest delayed ripening factors such as softening and red color development more than later ones. More recently, Liu et al. (2022) compared half and full rates of AVG applied to ‘Gala’ fruit at 7 and 21 days before the first harvest. AVG at half or full rates applied at 21 days before harvest delayed red color development, starch hydrolysis and loss of chlorophyll compared with fruit treated at 7 days or untreated. The effects of AVG treatment on firmness were inconsistent. AVG-treated fruit were firmer and greener than untreated fruit after storage at 4 °C for 3 months.
关于AVG施用时期对果实成熟和贮藏品质影响的信息有限。在早期研究中,Greene(2005)发现,在预期采收前1-2周施药可将落果控制延长至正常采收期之后,但在采收前4-6周施药比后期施药更能延缓软化因素和红色发育等成熟过程。最近,Liu等(2022)比较了在首次采收前7天和21天对‘Gala’果实施用半量和全量AVG的效果。在采收前21天施用半量或全量AVG,与采收前7天处理或未处理果实相比,延缓了红色发育、淀粉水解和叶绿素损失。AVG处理对硬度的影响不一致。AVG处理果实在4°C贮藏3个月后比未处理果实更硬、更绿。
‘Gala’ apples are susceptible to a physiological disorder, stem end flesh browning (SEFB), which develops first around the shoulder of the apples and then develops throughout the fruit as flesh browning (FB) (Watkins and Mattheis, 2019). FB development has become a limiting factor for long term storage of ‘Gala’ apples (Al Shoffe and Watkins, 2025; Argenta et al., 2021, 2023; DeEll et al., 2022; Lee et al., 2013; Nock et al., 2019), resulting in economic losses in the USA and other countries. FB incidence is higher at lower storage temperatures (0-1 °C) than at higher (2-3 °C) ones (Argenta et al., 2023; Mazzurana et al., 2016; Nock et al., 2019) but it is unclear whether the primary cause of FB in ‘Gala’ is the chilling stress or the advance of ripening and senescence (Argenta et al., 2023).
‘Gala’苹果易患一种生理失调——果梗端果肉褐变(SEFB),首先在苹果肩部周围发生,然后发展为全果果肉褐变(FB)(Watkins和Mattheis,2019)。FB的发生已成为‘Gala’苹果长期贮藏的限制因素(Al Shoffe和Watkins,2025;Argenta等,2021,2023;DeEll等,2022;Lee等,2013;Nock等,2019),在美国和其他国家造成经济损失。FB发生率在较低贮藏温度(0-1°C)下高于较高温度(2-3°C)(Argenta等,2023;Mazzurana等,2016;Nock等,2019),但尚不清楚‘Gala’FB的主要原因是冷害还是成熟和衰老的推进(Argenta等,2023)。
‘Gala’ strains have similar susceptibility to FB (Argenta et al., 2021), but higher disorder incidence is associated with later harvest dates (Argenta et al., 2021, 2023; Thewes et al., 2017) and larger fruit (Lee et al., 2013). IAD values (higher values reflect higher chlorophyll concentrations) at harvest were positively correlated with flesh firmness and negatively correlated with FB incidence (Doerflinger et al., 2019; Al Shoffe and Watkins, 2025).
‘Gala’品系对FB的易感性相似(Argenta等,2021),但较高的失调发生率与较晚的采收期(Argenta等,2021,2023;Thewes等,2017)和较大的果实(Lee等,2013)相关。采收时的IAD值(较高值反映较高的叶绿素浓度)与果肉硬度呈正相关,与FB发生率呈负相关(Doerflinger等,2019;Al Shoffe和Watkins,2025)。
Several trials with AVG application on ‘Gala’ have found that fruit maturation was delayed (Doerflinger et al., 2024; Magazin et al., 2012; Ortega-Salazar and Torres, 2026; Petri et al., 2007; Phan-Thien et al., 2004) and decay and stem end splitting of the fruit reduced (Liu et al., 2022; Steffens et al., 2005) compared with untreated fruit. Our preliminary trials have indicated that AVG can be a factor in decreasing the risk of FB development in ‘Gala’ apples, although variable. Nock et al. (2019) found that AVG did not affect FB incidence, although preharvest 1-MCP reduced it. No effects of AVG on flesh breakdown were found by Anese et al. (2020).
几项对‘Gala’施用AVG的试验发现,与未处理果实相比,果实成熟被延缓(Doerflinger等,2024;Magazin等,2012;Ortega-Salazar和Torres,2026;Petri等,2007;Phan-Thien等,2004),腐烂和果梗端开裂减少(Liu等,2022;Steffens等,2005)。我们的初步试验表明,AVG可能是降低‘Gala’苹果FB发生风险的一个因素,尽管效果不稳定。Nock等(2019)发现AVG不影响FB发生率,尽管采前1-MCP降低了FB发生率。Anese等(2020)未发现AVG对果肉崩溃的影响。
The availability of Harvista™ to the industry has allowed application of PGRs closer to harvest and thereby reduce the negative effects of treatment on red color development. While the issue of delayed color development of ‘Gala’ apples by AVG is managed by use of lower rates, there is interest in applying the chemical closer to the harvest time. The objective of this study was to compare the effects of the standard apple industry treatments of half rates as split applications with full rates of AVG closer to harvest on fruit quality and susceptibility of fruit to physiological disorders. Although warmer storage temperatures such as 3 °C and use of low oxygen (0.5%) can reduce FB incidence of ‘Gala’ apples (Nock et al., 2019), we used the standard storage recommendation of 0.5 °C and 2% oxygen/1-2% carbon dioxide (Watkins et al., 2016) in this study to increase the potential for FB development. Fruit were not treated with postharvest 1-MCP to ensure that the effects of AVG on firmness and other quality factors could be investigated directly.
Harvista™在产业中的可用性使得植物生长调节剂可以在更接近采收时施用,从而减少处理对红色发育的负面影响。虽然AVG延缓‘Gala’苹果着色的问题通过使用较低浓度得到管理,但人们有兴趣在更接近采收时施用该化学物质。本研究的目标是比较苹果产业标准处理——分次施用半量与临近采收时施用全量AVG——对果实品质和果实对生理失调易感性的影响。尽管较高的贮藏温度如3°C和使用低氧(0.5%)可以降低‘Gala’苹果的FB发生率(Nock等,2019),但本研究使用了标准贮藏推荐条件0.5°C和2%氧气/1-2%二氧化碳(Watkins等,2016)以增加FB发生的可能性。果实未进行采后1-MCP处理,以确保可以直接研究AVG对硬度和其它品质因素的影响。
···
2.2 Harvest and storage
Only fruit with ≥60% red color were harvested. Fruit were harvested from 6 trees per replicate three times in 2020, 9/8 (H1), 9/15 (H2) and 9/22 (H3), and two times in 2021, 9/14 (H1) and 9/21 (H2). Only two harvests occurred in 2021 because of advanced red color development and maturation of the fruit. On each harvest date, containers of approximately 40 fruit each plus 10 fruit for evaluation of harvest indices and quality, were harvested from each replicate set of trees for each treatment Fruit were transported to the postharvest laboratory at Ithaca, NY, for analysis and storage. The containers of fruit from each treatment were then loaded into 0.9 m3 CA chambers (Storage Control Systems, Sparta, MI, USA) in a 0.5 °C storage room to cool overnight. Atmospheres of 2 kPa O2/2 kPa CO2 were then established within 48 h, checked hourly and maintained with an ICA 61/CGS 610 CA Control System (International Controlled Atmosphere Ltd., Kent, U.K.) modified with flow controllers for the experimental chambers (Storage Control Systems, Sparta, MI, USA). Fruit were stored for 4 and 8 months in 2020, and 5 and 9 months in 2021. Fruit quality was evaluated after 1 and 7 d at 20 °C.

